194 James Drive, Silverton

(012) 804-8031

navrae@tlu.co.za

Members / Friends matters: ledesake@tlu.co.za

International Bulletin October 30, 2015

“The downhill path is easy, but there’s no turning back.” (Christina Georgina Rossetti, British born poet. 1830 – 1894)

THE SLIPPERY SLOPE TO FREEDOM

Freedom is an intoxicating word used masterfully by revolutionary leaders over the centuries. Rarely is responsibility and cost mentioned as corollaries. With modern freedom comes the pickings – not quite the raping and pillaging of old – but to the victor, the spoils. To millions, political freedom holds the promise of something for nothing, unfettered by liability and obligation.

The Freedom Charter, the ANC’s guiding document officially adopted on June 26, 1955, declared that basic education should be free and compulsory, and “higher education shall be open to all by means of state allowances and scholarships awarded on the basis of merit.”

A resolution adopted at the ANC PWV region Policy Conference 9 – 10 May 1992 declared that the ANC is committed to “the progressive expansion of the provision of free education at tertiary levels….subject to the availability of funds”.

When ANC election promises were subsequently made, “subject to the availability of funds” was not emphasized. This same omission applied to the promises of free electricity, water and housing. The economic feasibility of keeping the promises was conveniently swept under the carpet, and the chickens have now come home to roost. Nothing is free of course –someone has to pay.

The higher education debacle and the concomitant violence and student upheavals now wracking South Africa are the result of the ANC’s trumping of ideology over reality. Higher Education Minister Blade Nzimande is hoist on his own petard. Offering tertiary education to millions of people who come from poor backgrounds and cannot pay, or whose academic achievements could never give reason for them to expect a successful journey through a university degree course, was a triumph of political expediency over prudence.

The facts speak for themselves. The graduation rate among undergraduate students in South Africa’s then 23 public universities was 15% in 2013. The rate for Master’s students was 20% and for doctoral students 12%. (Monash University says a healthy graduation rate would be 50%). These figures emanate from Minister Nzimande’s own department – its first statistical report published in 2013 which looked at “the size and shape of post-school education and training in South Africa”. (Black African students comprised 78% of contact students (those on campus) and 83% of all students enrolled in distance education). So why has Minister Nzimande’s department allowed student registrations to increase every year, more than doubling from 495 355 in 1994 to 1 002 110 in 2014?

The state allocates R9 billion a year to student subsidies, while operating subsidies to the country’s 26 universities total R72 billion over three years. One can imagine the huge loss incurred because of the 800 000 students who didn’t make it in 2014, let alone the hundreds of thousands who dropped out over the past twenty odd years. What has become of them? Nobody appears to want to criticize Minister Nzimande for fear of appearing as if they don’t want the “previously disadvantaged” to demand and get the right to tertiary education. But education is not a right. It is a privilege.

Millions of talented people throughout the world cannot even hope to obtain a university degree (let alone register for one!) because they simply cannot afford it. Others obtain loans which they have to repay for years into their careers, while some study via correspondence, working at night and at weekends. Some obtain bursaries if they are very clever. Others are subsidized by their governments with the proviso that they work off their debt via state employment for years after graduation. There’s no free ride with a university education.

PRIMARY/SECONDARY EDUCATION

 

The problems start with South Africa’s primary education. Setting a matriculation pass mark of 30% made South Africa the world’s laughing stock. Again, ideology triumphed over common sense. It’s the numbers that matter to a seriously inept government, not the quality of the pass, and herein lies the rub. Education is the start, not the finish.

Getting a degree is the first step. There’s much work to do after that to attain any sort of success. Education is an intrinsic ingredient of a culture, not a ticket to a cushy job, an expense account and trips overseas. It’s what you do with it that counts, not the fact that you have the piece of paper. In the hands of the ANC government, the matriculation certificate was in danger of “meaninglessness, worthlessness and irrelevance” declared Mr. Tinyiko Maluleke, deputy vice chancellor of student affairs at the University of Johannesburg (UJ) in January 2014.

This peculiar attitude towards education as a ticket to life’s perks was evidenced in January 2012 when one person was killed and many injured when 5 000 aspirant students stampeded to register at the gates of UJ. (In 2011 UJ received more than 85 000 applications for fewer than 12 000 places in its under-graduate courses). Many students don’t know what they want to study. Many believe they will get a “good job” somewhere in the civil service, whether they are suited to it or not: and why not, when hundreds of thousands of their fellow ANC cadres have achieved this.

Instead of explaining to their supporters what a university degree entails, that one’s studies should be tailored to one’s aptitude, skills and, yes, shortcomings, “free education” is proffered because it was embodied in the Freedom Charter.

ECONOMIC SUPPORT

 

South Africa’s economic structure is one of the most warped in the world. Thirteen percent of South Africa’s 53 million people pay income tax, while 36% of the country’s budget is allocated to wages for a bloated public service whose lack of capacity has led to the birth of a parallel privately- funded service industry that has expanded in direct proportion to the dissipation of government services in, inter alia, the security, schooling, postal and health sectors. South Africans thus pay twice for services, while the small tax base foots the bill for 15 million welfare recipients and the billions lost through government corruption and inefficiency. There is no shortage of grandiose government plans, many based on ideology and hot air. No thought to the cost is given. The government’s National Development Plan sees 10 million people obtaining bachelor’s degrees by 2030, surely pie in the sky especially in the face of the government’s current penurious economic plight that has resulted in riots, destruction and scholar disappointment.

Where will the money come from to foot the looming tertiary education bill? The cookie jar is dangerously low. Since 2007, SA has accumulated the most debt as a percentage of GDP of the 14 emerging markets monitored by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS). It is believed that right now there is a need for R2,6 billion to close the student-funding gap. The Department of Education and Training has cash surpluses, yet that department’s avaricious gaze is now focusing on the usual suspects: the private sector, the people who work hard to feed the taxation piggy bank from which the rest of the country lives. Minister Nzimande is looking for R37 billion over the next three years, plus R9,5 billion for student funding.

The minister declared the public sector doesn’t have enough money. (The government should have thought of that when they were promising free everything at pre-election rallies.) Dr. Nzimande is specifically eyeing the mining industry, currently on its knees because of crippling strike action, lack of capacity due to electricity constraints, ageing infrastructure and low world commodity prices. Then of course his government can always further tax the rich.

It is fruitless to remind the government of the billions wasted and stolen through state corruption, mismanagement, tenders awarded to friends and the distended government wage bill. This falls on deaf ears. The fact that the Hawks are now conducting a forensic audit into the disappearance of funds allocated to the National Student Financial Aid Scheme(NSFAS) is not mentioned by Dr. Nzimande. Corruption within his own department has contributed to the current mess.

Since 1991 NSFAS paid out R50 billion to 1,5 million students. The debt recovery from students is poor, and the scheme cannot get money back from graduates who are now employed. Only R247 million has been recovered so far this year. R9 billion was disbursed in 2014/5 to 414 802 beneficiaries. The recovery of these debts is a struggle, and is put down to “inefficiencies” according to the chief financial officer of Wits University. This mentality of getting an education for free is already endemic, even among graduates who should know better, and to change this mindset will be difficult. It shows a woeful lack of comprehension as to how a modern economy works – that everything has to be paid for.

In a brilliant critique, The Centre for Development and Enterprise’s Moeletsi Mbeki declared that South Africa’s “Tunisia Day” was not far off. He was certainly prescient in this respect considering the depth and breadth of student resentment and destruction over the past few weeks. The welfare state is upon us, he says –if you keep getting everything for free then you lose the sense of its value. Hear! Hear!

Kategorie:

Deel dit:

International Bulletin October 30, 2015