Pres Cyril Ramaphosa’s comments that the ANC does not endorse a nationalisation policy do not put TLU SA at ease that all land (and property) will not eventually be in the hands of the government.
After the reply on the presidential budget, Pres Ramaphosa said that the ANC wants people to own land and not the state. The issue came to light this week after the ANC and EFF suggested new amendments during a meeting of the ad hoc committee on the revision of Section 25 of the Constitution. They made suggestions about the guardianship of land, the cutoff date for restitution claims, and the courts’ role in compensation.
“What is the difference between nationalisation and expropriation without compensation,” says Mr Henry Geldenhuys, the president of TLU SA. “With nationalisation, the land is taken from the legal owners all at once. With expropriation without compensation – land is taken piece by piece from the legal owners at a nil rate. In five to ten years, there will be no difference in ownership.”
With its guardianship over water resources, the state already proved that it is not adept at managing the responsibility properly. It is clear from our polluted water sources, poor quality of water and the shortcomings in providing water for human consumption. People now have to buy water out of their own pockets without support from the state. We are doomed if the state implements guardianship over everything.
“They should seriously rethink the notion of nationalisation,” says Mr Geldenhuys. “Look at the consequences of such decisions. The economy dwindles, and investors trust is taking a knock. Just a week ago, S & P and Fitch set the country’s credit rating at BB-. Even though it is unchanged, it is certainly not good. This week StatsSA reported that unemployment reached a record high for the third sequential quarter. It stands at 43%.
“The government neglects the responsibilities of the state. Further amendments steal the opportunity for growth and indeed, the future of each South African.”
Issued by: TLU SA
Date: 4 June 2021
Enquiries: Mr Henry Geldenhuys, President TLU SA, Cell.: 083 560 1273
Mr Bennie van Zyl, General Manager TLU SA, Cell.: 082 466 4470








